GTA VI's Concorde Problem
Concorde was a marvel of engineering. For nearly three decades, you could travel from London to New York at twice the speed of sound; a journey across the Atlantic would take a mere three-and-a-half hours, half the time it takes today. And this was not some kind of experimental prototype, it wasn’t a Virgin Galactic or a Blue Origin, this was an ordinary scheduled passenger flight (albeit with an eye-watering fare), taking off from the same airport that could take you to Peking or Edinburgh.
Concorde was the zenith of an extraordinary period for technological optimism in aviation. The piston engine had given way to the jet engine; the Jumbo Jet had brought long-haul travel to the masses. It was only natural that the next advancement would be supersonic flight. After all, if engineers could make an aircraft fly twice as fast, why wouldn’t they? The possibilities seemed endless.
And yet, in 2003, Concorde made its final flight. Why? We still knew how to make them; the planes didn’t suddenly stop working. The crash in Paris three years earlier certainly hastened its demise, but the fundamental issue was that the economics just couldn’t scale. It was so expensive to build, maintain and operate, and its market was too constrained. So we let what we thought was the future of aviation slip through our fingers and the industry instead went in a different direction.
I suspect the video games industry is approaching its own Concorde moment.
Grand Theft Auto VI is set to be released in mere days and by all indications it will be a runaway commercial success: it will certainly be the biggest media product since the Bible and possible since Mao Zedong’s Little Red Book. What it will not do, however, is vindicate the big-budget, mega-project, super duper blockbuster business model that has come to dominate AAA game development. Rockstar has every advantage out of the gate in terms of both the resources they’ve been able to pour into the game and the public’s anticipation for it; but even a spectacular return for Rockstar would not prove that the rest of the industry can afford to follow it. Nor would it tell us whether all that extra money time, polygons, gigahertz and teraflops pays off in the sales figures, critical reception, or what we see as being possible from the medium.
GTA V was a fantastic game, but it was a freakishly successful product because of the extraordinary circumstances into which it was born. The initial release of the game in 2013 was when the two major game consoles, the Xbox 360 and the PlayStation 3, were at their most mature. Microsoft had finally worked out how to manufacture a console that wasn’t a defective wreck, and developers for the PS3 had started to get the hang of its alien Cell architecture. Importantly, the consoles had also gone through price reductions and hardware tweaks which put them into more homes than ever before. Because the consoles were at the end of their lifecycle, Rockstar had to squeeze every ounce of performance out of systems which were first shipped in 2005 for the 360 and 2006 for the PS3. While anyone with a PC would struggle to get a modern game to run on that kind of ageing hardware and, thanks to a lot of optimisation and visual trickery, the game was still very much playable and it looked great.
GTA Online followed, kickstarting a long run of expansions, DLC and reasons to get Shark Cards. Then the Xbox One and PlayStation 4 arrived, and the game got a next-gen re-release which brought in new players and persuaded existing players to purchase it a second time. Then the PC release. Then there was the pandemic, followed by the release of the Xbox Series X|S and PlayStation 5 and yet another re-release of GTA V. That extraordinary run is a benchmark that GTA VI cannot count on replicating by simply making “GTA V, but better.”
But Can it Run Crysis?
When GTA VI comes out, it will be the most hotly anticipated game ever, and one of the most expensive games ever produced. I’m going to make a prediction and say that it will be generally well received. But think about how the series has progressed over time; think about the jump from 2D to 3D when GTA III was released in 2001. Think about the jump to the living, breathing high-definition world of Liberty City when GTA IV came out in 2008. Think about the expanded open world and how much more you could do when GTA V came out in 2013. If GTA VI comes out and merely looks a bit better and plays a bit better, my response to that will be: yeah, it bloody well should, but after thirteen years between instalments and a budget rumoured to be in excess of $1 billion, how much more has all that investment made possible?
There was a running joke among PC gamers: “But can it run Crysis?” Released in 2007, Crysis was so extraordinarily demanding that running it at maximum settings was less a reasonable expectation than an opportunity to show off a ludicrously expensive computer. The joke worked because Crysis was exceptional, not just because very few games at the time were that demanding on your hardware, but because it was a marked step up. You could see the sprawling jungles, the destructible environments, the lighting effects and immediately understand why your PC was struggling and why that game was a shorthand for power-hungry games.
In the twenty years since, games have become vastly more sophisticated, but how many of those improvements are noticeable without a side-by-side screenshot? Can you honestly say the jump from 2015 to 2025 is as noticeable as that between 2005 and 2015? The problem isn't that games have stopped getting better, it's that we're spending inordinate amounts of money and computing power making them better in ways that are less important.
Here’s a different Rockstar property which I think will illustrate what I’m talking about. In Red Dead Redemption 2, they programmed the horses so that their testes would shrink if it got cold. With all due respect (which is none, by the way), what kind of joyless, pixel-counting bore gets excited by this crap? How many development hours, stand-up meetings and Kanban boards go, in effect, towards jingling a set of perfectly rendered keys in front of an infant?
There is obviously such a thing as artistic vision and I would hate for the industry to be solely dedicated to chasing the almighty dollar, and I agree that instinct has driven a lot of the live-service slop we’ve seen over the past decade. But at a certain point a competent project manager does need to hop into that stand-up meeting and go, “fellas, can we make the scrotum a stretch and just get this damn thing shipped?”
GTA V could run on a machine with only 512 MB of memory. Granted, that was a console, and developers have a few tricks up their sleeves to squeeze more juice out of one than an equivalent PC. But if you bought a gaming PC in 2020 with your COVID stimulus cheque (like I did), it wouldn’t have taken to long for that system to become virtually obsolete just when the price of components went up.
And how many people are either buying a game they wouldn’t have otherwise or are spending more time playing a game because it has individually rendered strands of hair, or NPCs who pick up objects with individually animated fingers? And conversely, because of this blown out development cycle, how many games which otherwise would have been made have been sucked into this black hole? How many people who played GTA V when it first came out have aged out of the hobby because they’re now so busy that “hundreds of hours of content” is less an invitation than a threat? How does any of this work in a world where you can’t get people to pay $120 for mere content anymore, when the entertainment options available to them are cheaper and more expansive than ever before?
The Price of Perfection
Look, in all likelihood, GTA VI is going to be a banger; but at what cost? There’s obviously a financial cost, the upshot of which is that you need to sell a hell of a lot of copies and eke as much money as possible out of your players to earn a decent return. The more money and time that gets poured into these games, the higher the stakes become, and a game that would otherwise be considered a runaway financial success becomes a financial disappointment or even a commercial failure because it had such a threshold to meet.
There’s nothing wrong with making an ambitious and excruciatingly expensive game, the same way there’s nothing wrong with wanting to make a plane that goes at twice the speed of sound. But it’s not ambitious to make a product that won’t break even if it doesn’t hit fifty gazillion sales, it’s just reckless. We don’t live in a post-scarcity world: developers need to be paid, publishers need to make a return on their investment, and studios need to make enough money to keep the lights on. If they don’t – either because they’ve completely lost the plot and have spent six years perfecting the physics of individual blades of grass, or because they’ve made a game nobody wants to buy – then eventually they’ll close.
The Games That Never Got Made
And that sucks, especially when people lose their jobs and franchises get mothballed, but that’s not some kind of terrible injustice inflicted upon the arts by capitalism, that’s the reality of producing a commercial product.
There’s another cost though, and that’s the opportunity cost. With all this talent being sucked into these mega projects, how many other games aren’t being made? How many interesting ideas never go beyond a pitch meeting because teams of people are dedicated to ensuring the pedestrians in Vice City have unique walking patterns? And when games get so expensive to make, when a mere million sales won’t make the grade, are publishers going to be willing to take risks? Are we going to see truly innovative and dangerous games made outside small independent studios if the AAA industry keeps up its current trajectory?
The Concorde was a magnificent machine, and it's a genuine shame that we no longer live in a world where you can have breakfast in London and arrive in New York before you've finished digesting it. But its demise didn't mean the end of ambition in aviation. We didn't abandon Boeing and Airbus and decide that the future belonged to a small collective of people flying Cessnas. We built the enormous A380, betting on a future of giant aircraft connecting global hubs. Aircraft such as the 787 and A350, offered another kind of progress: flying further and more efficiently, and opening up more direct routes. That is another way to measure progress: how many more journeys become possible, rather than how quickly a few people can make one.
I don't think the answer for video games is to declare the death of AAA development and leave the future of the medium to independent studios, any more than the answer for aviation was to abandon the jumbo jet. There's nothing inherently wrong with spending hundreds of millions of dollars and employing thousands of people to make something extraordinary. But there is something profoundly unimaginative about spending ever-greater sums of money and ever-longer periods of time making essentially the same thing but a bit prettier. If you’re going to spend that much money and time, why not try to give us something new?
I don’t know what the industry’s next big achievement is, but I don’t want it to be a bigger open world, more polygons, more teraflops. We should be trying to expand what’s possible. Concorde’s fate suggests that the future doesn’t always look like a faster version of the present. I want the games industry to find its equivalent of opening new routes: more possibilities for players, and room for more games to get made.
